37 Old Route 9W
New Windsor Township, NY 12553
27 & 37 Old Rt 9W, St Thomas Church · Spécialité Bien À vendre · 226 m²

Rand Commercial is pleased to present the exclusive offering of 27 & 37 Old Route 9W -- a historic church campus situated on 3.20+ contiguous acres in the Town of New Windsor, Orange County, New York. The property is owned by The Episcopal Diocese of New York and represents a rare opportunity to acquire an irreplaceable 1847 stone Gothic Revival church, meeting hall, and residential dwelling on a commercially zoned parcel with prominent Old Route 9W frontage and sweeping Hudson River views. The small stone building was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2006.
Zoned Neighborhood Commercial (NC) by the Town of New Windsor, the site accommodates a broad range of permitted uses by right including places of worship, professional offices, retail, eating and drinking establishments, and service businesses. The property is offered strictly as-is, where-is. Qualifying nonprofit or municipal purchasers may be eligible to restore the previously held tax-exempt status, which could significantly reduce long-term carrying costs.
PROPERTY SUMMARY
Address 27 & 37 Old Route 9W, New Windsor, NY 12553 Municipality Town of New Windsor, Orange County, New York
Tax Parcels Parcel 1: 9-2-7.1 | Parcel 2: 9-2-7.2 Property Type Religious / Institutional
Zoning NC -- Neighborhood Commercial (Town of New Windsor)
Total Land Area 3.20+ Acres (Two Contiguous Parcels)
Total Building Area 7,558+ SF Gross (Three Structures) Interest Offered
Fee Simple Estate Sale Condition As-Is, Where-Is -- Both Parcels Together Asking Price $825,000
Flood Zone Zone X -- Outside Floodplains (FEMA Panel 36071C0332E, 8/3/2009)
Utilities Municipal Water & Sewer Deed Restrictions None noted adversely affecting value Sales History No known sales or transfers within prior 5 years Leases No leases in place/.
Fee Simple, unencumbered Current Tax Status Tax-exempt status lapsed 2025; may be restored for qualifying nonprofit or municipal buyer.
Please use our offer form at the end of the Offering Memorandum with proof of funds.